A judge in California has decided not to dismiss the lawsuit Nomi Abadi filed against Danny Elfman, where she accuses him of bad behavior back in 2016.
Los Angeles Judge Gail Killefer ruled that Abadi’s case can continue, claiming Elfman spread lies about her in a statement to Rolling Stone in July 2023. Elfman had denied the accusations, calling them "vicious and wholly false."
The judge focused on the phrase "wholly false," noting there were text messages where Elfman sent nude photos to Abadi and mentioned being unclothed. She said this suggests some truth to Abadi’s claims.
Fans might find it surprising how these things unfold so publicly.
Elfman’s own words about "naked romping" in Paris with Abadi contradict his denial, the judge pointed out. Even if their views on their relationship differ, Abadi’s evidence shows her claims aren’t entirely baseless.
Abadi’s messages with Elfman indicate she might prove Elfman knowingly lied by calling her allegations "wholly false," which is why the case can proceed.
Editor’s Picks
In his 2023 statement to Rolling Stone, Elfman insisted Abadi’s claims were untrue, saying he didn’t realize she had feelings for him and aimed to break up his marriage. He believed she wanted revenge when he distanced himself.
The judge remarked that this part of Elfman’s statement seemed more like a false claim than just his opinion.
She also dismissed Elfman’s argument that his statement was protected because it was a warning letter to Rolling Stone. The judge viewed it as more of a press release, given he allowed the publication to share his statement.
"If Elfman could make statements and use the litigation privilege as cover, it would undermine the privilege’s purpose," the judge wrote.
Elfman’s lawyer, Camille Vasquez, mentioned they plan to appeal the ruling, expressing optimism the Court of Appeal will dismiss the case.
Related Content
Abadi began her defamation lawsuit on July 10, 2024, claiming Elfman’s actions damaged her reputation and career dreams.
Vasquez, who once defended Johnny Depp, argued Abadi filed her lawsuit too late. However, the judge clarified the timing started when Rolling Stone published its article, not when Elfman’s letter was sent.
Abadi’s lawyer, Eric George, did not comment, though he has experience from Heard’s earlier legal battles.
